“Human history began with an act of disobedience, and it is not unlikely that it will be terminated by an act of obedience.” — Erich Fromm
The question of when or if to resist authority is central to organized human life. As Fromm’s comment suggests, the mythic traditions of the Hebrews and Greeks, and their emphasis on acts of defiance against God and gods, cast a long shadow. But as the gods recede, or become more symbolic, debates about the validity, limits, sources, and potential abuses of governmental authority become prominent.
One of our texts, Sophocles’ play Antigone, so effectively frames these issues that the title character’s fierce and principled resistance to her King’s seemingly godlike authority resonates as powerfully today as it did on the Athenian stage. The issues at stake in this play, and in the other works we will discuss, are at stake anywhere that humans connect the grounds for their adherence or resistance to authority on principles that transcend mere appeals to power, expediency, and self-interest. These issues are not unique to particular cultures, periods of history, or forms of government.
In this course, we bring together a diverse collection of philosophical, political, historical and literary texts designed to facilitate and provoke critical exploration of the complicated relationship between authority and resistance. Such exploration is not always easy or welcome because, in much of the world, obedience to authority is thought to bring safety, security, and order, while resistance brings chaos, anxiety, even death. But we will consider where and when resistance might be justified, whether it is a futile and/or destructive impulse; and whether its persistence is evidence of an essential connection to human growth.
We invite you to join us in our attempt to better understand the principles at play where orders are issued, decisions are made, obedience demanded, and resistance ensues.
Image credits for poster:
- Antigone donnant la sépulture à Polynice, by Sebastian Norblin (1825), photo by VladoubidoOo, licensed CC BY-SA 3.0 on Wikimedia Commons
- Che Guevara, public domain on Wikimedia Commons
- Protest sign image, by S Pakhrin, licensed CC BY 2.0 on Flickr
- Big Brother Inc. image, licensed CC BY 2.0 on Flickr
The above poster is licensed CC BY-SA 4.0, by Brianne Orr-Álvarez
[June 17, 2017]
- Seminar LB1: John Barker (Anthropology)
- Seminar LB2: Robert Crawford (Political Science)
- Seminar LB3: Brianne Orr-Alvarez (French, Hispanic, Italian Studies)
- Seminar LB4: Andrew Connolly (English)
While we update this section, please visit the UBC Bookstore website for your texts because UBC profs have placed their book orders at The Bookstore.
The Bookstore has now posted texts for 2017W, so you’ll find the Arts One Group B books as well as for any electives you have. Make sure to check back once in a while in case there are updates.
You don’t have to purchase your books from the UBC Bookstore, although you are welcome to do so if you like. They also offer the option of used books, renting, and e-books too. These are the books ordered by your profs, including the ISBN versions that they want you to use:
Updated: August 17, 2017